Thursday, May 23, 2013

Personal Income Tax for Creative Common Musicians

This is not legal advice. Leave audio feedback at (512) 686-6329.

I have a few thoughts on Doug's post about personal income tax consequences for musicians. I think Doug was a bit pessimistic in his interpretation of when musicians are engaged in a separate trade or business, the business of being a musician. A taxpayer is engaged in a trade or business when they are regularly involved with an activity for the purpose of generating profit. See Groetzinger if you're interested in finding out more about what constitutes a trade or business. (Professional gambling can as long as you do it regularly and mean to make a profit.)

Doug had some concerns that musicians who release under creative commons may not qualify as engaging in a separate trade or business because they do not profit from the distribution of their music recordings. I would still argue that most musicians would still be engaged in a trade or business despite not charging for their music. I see musicians as offering two categories of goods and services: recorded music and live performance services. I think most musicians who release music under creative commons are giving away their recorded music in order to promote their performance services. Releasing music under creative commons is like a restaurant that gives away free samples. While the restaurant is not trying to make money on those particular samples it is attempting to use those samples to promote its profitable services. The fact that a musician chooses to give away their music should not disqualify him from being treated as engaging in a trade or business for tax purposes.

Musicians still need to meet the regularity and profit motive requirements in order to be treated as being engaged in a trade or business. Doug and I agreed that this is where some musicians might have trouble qualifying as being engaged in a trade or business. An important point to note is that taxpayers can be involved in more than one trade or business so having a day job does not interfere with being considered a musician by trade. However, how much time one spends doing music is certainly relevant. Sporadic practice and infrequent performances might keep some musicians from qualifying as being engaged in a trade or business. I guess the main difference between my view and Doug's view on the subject is on what exactly constitutes a profit motive. I am fairly optimistic, in Groetzinger the court found a professional gambler to be engaged in a trade or business. While many musicians might not profit from their music, I'm pretty sure the probability of making money as a gambler is somewhat lower.

I am generally optimistic that most regular musicians are engaged in a trade or business as long as they have some hope of making money on their music one day.


  1. Anonymous08:12

    This was a good suggestion that you put up here...dude…..hope that it benefits all the ones who land up here. 

    Trades Jobs

  2. Perfection is exactly what a bride desires for her wedding ceremony. While the bride is definitely the principal Karen Millen Outlet attraction during the ceremony, her bridesmaid will have to also seem pretty also. Right after all, they can be the persons who will march across the aisle to begin with. Brisbane has a number of the most wonderful locations which are excellent for weddings. Due to that, Bridesmaid Dresses Karen Millen Sale Brisbane and other apparels to the rest with the entourage are usually purchased while in the stated place as well. As selecting internet based has now turn out to get likely, Bridesmaid Dresses Brisbane has also made their products obtainable on the net. Buying online is obviously much more hassle-free than driving across the city on hunt for a boutique that Mont Blanc Pens Sale UK could offer the dresses that you might need. Through the use of your preferred search engine instrument, you¡¯re able to basically Chrome Hearts Online hunt for the greatest bridesmaids dresses Brisbane on the web straight at the comfort of the personal home.

  3. A brand new continues to be spotted which has a Sandhill motorised hoist head, an issue involving imprinting that seemingly took place Parajumpers Jackets on the get started of your real goose's existence. The goose gotten at Inspiration Shape Preserve with crane flocks above the weekend too as earlier too. Faust noticed him or her with Moose Knuckles Canada his adopted group on using the web video per week in the past and published it on Canada Goose Women Jackets YouTube. The query now's regardless if or not the goose can progress although applying cranes to become ready to Oregon too as Ca plantation regions whenever they lift off daily currently. If this describes correct, the goose girl perhaps Canada Goose Sale Outlet born ahead of the cranes' individual colts. The possibility of which is how the cranes may possibly and after that give up their exclusive ovum.