Friday, December 28, 2012

Why Fair Use Is Important

This is not legal advice. Leave audio feedback at (512) 686-6329.

Issue: Should plaintiff's bear the burden of rebutting fair use in their case in chief?

I'd like to start by saying I hope any readers have had a great Thanksgiving and I'm sorry its been so long seen I posted, the holidays can be hectic, especially if you have law school finals.

I believe fair use is the most important aspect of American Copyright law because it is really meant to achieve the purpose of copyright law which is to promote the progress of science and the useful arts. Which is not to say that other aspects of copyright law do not promote science and the useful arts but fair use is an important balance to the economic incentives given to copyright holders and the right of others to communicate freely.

Doug posed an interesting thesis that rebutting fair use should be an aspect of a prima facie case for copyright infringement. I disagree mostly for procedural reasons. Lawsuits start with a plaintiff filing a complaint and then the defendant filing an answer. Then there can be a motion for a judgment on the pleading if it is clear that no real case exists. (or in some rare debt collection cases I believe a plaintiff can win on judgment on the pleadings.) Requiring plaintiffs to rebut a case for fair use in their pleading before discovery would frustrate the doctrine of fair use because fair use is a fact intensive doctrine. Judges need to have a strong grasp on all relevant facts in order to determine whether a use is fair or not. Forcing plaintiffs to allege that fair use is not possible before the plaintiffs have had an opportunity to go through discovery would result in good cases being thrown out because plaintiffs' attorney were unable to obtain all the facts through the procedural process.

As to whether the plaintiff should bear a greater burden to rebut a defense of fair use at trial is an irrelevant issue. The Doctrine of fair use is a four factor balancing test. If a defendant raises the defense in the defendant's answer, then at trial the defendant will argue for the factors they believe favor fair use and the plaintiffs argue for the factors they believe will rebut fair use. Essentially I don't think a shift in the burden would do much unless Doug is arguing to change from the balancing test to something else entirely different. I just do not see the need for change because fair use adequately balances copyright owners economic incentives with everyone's first amendment right to free speech.


8 comments:

  1. very interesting information! .
    Debt Recovery Singapore

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the post, I really learned a lot regarding Debt Collection Singapore

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Together with the fast advancement of modern-day imitation engineering, replica products are getting to be a growing number of well known Goyard Tote with the consumers. People are willing to devote revenue on those replicas for their super mirror image excellent quality and reduced costs as compared using the originals. Get designer Goyard Tote Outlet handbags as an example, replicas like LV, GUCCI, CHANEL, HERMES, DIOR.. might be noticed everywhere. And people today can hardly tell the main difference from your originals. Replicas are now helping increasingly more go through luxury, helping luxury style be spreaded Christian Louboutin Bags Outlet across the globe. Anyway, individuals get rather puzzled and Gucci Bags Outlet Sale skeptical when it comes to determining to buy trend designer handbags. Here I would want to Sale Michael Kors Handbags share with you my complete comprehending of individuals diverse Grades of designer handbags in accordance to my go through. For objects below Grade A, we phone them Grade B. In contrast with the genuine goods, only Brand will be the identical because the authentic Longchamp Tote Bags ones. Goods of Grade B are just embossed with genuine Emblem, they are often viewed and offered even through the street by vendors at especially low rates. We call them trash items and they are very easily distinguishable. As for products of Grade A, as far as I understand, you can find 6 grades that are stated above within the market place.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Perfection is exactly what a bride desires for her wedding ceremony. While the bride is definitely the principal Karen Millen Outlet attraction during the ceremony, her bridesmaid will have to also seem pretty also. Right after all, they can be the persons who will march across the aisle to begin with. Brisbane has a number of the most wonderful locations which are excellent for weddings. Due to that, Bridesmaid Dresses Karen Millen Sale Brisbane and other apparels to the rest with the entourage are usually purchased while in the stated place as well. As selecting internet based has now turn out to get likely, Bridesmaid Dresses Brisbane has also made their products obtainable on the net. Buying online is obviously much more hassle-free than driving across the city on hunt for a boutique that Mont Blanc Pens Sale UK could offer the dresses that you might need. Through the use of your preferred search engine instrument, you¡¯re able to basically Chrome Hearts Online hunt for the greatest bridesmaids dresses Brisbane on the web straight at the comfort of the personal home.

    ReplyDelete
  7. A brand new continues to be spotted which has a Sandhill motorised hoist head, an issue involving imprinting that seemingly took place Parajumpers Jackets on the get started of your real goose's existence. The goose gotten at Inspiration Shape Preserve with crane flocks above the weekend too as earlier too. Faust noticed him or her with Moose Knuckles Canada his adopted group on using the web video per week in the past and published it on Canada Goose Women Jackets YouTube. The query now's regardless if or not the goose can progress although applying cranes to become ready to Oregon too as Ca plantation regions whenever they lift off daily currently. If this describes correct, the goose girl perhaps Canada Goose Sale Outlet born ahead of the cranes' individual colts. The possibility of which is how the cranes may possibly and after that give up their exclusive ovum.

    ReplyDelete
  8. A Nike shoes-Turbo Charge Helps To make The Standard Nike footwear Philosophy So Exciting Mary Jo White, the nominee to go the Filing, provides inform lawmakers on Tuesday that she will carry a "bold and unrelenting" enforcement plan in the direction of Nike Shox Norge agency if she has confirmed as a consequence of the Senate. Investors and many forms of marketplace participants really have to know which the area folks markets is degree and this all wrongdoers -individual and institutional ... is going to be aggressively pursued with Nike Free run Sverige the SEC," mentioned White in ready testimony launched earlier than her confirmation hearing ahead of Senate Banking Committee.Proceeding aggressively against wrongdoers isn't only the appropriate point to try, just about all delivers to discourage Men Vans Half Cab Pro the sharp and unlawful practices of other individuals," White extra. White built a popularity as remaining Vans Shoes Outlet a hard-nosed Manhattan federal prosecutor ahead of relocating to private practice Nike Free Run Sverige Billiga for your past Ten many years your SEC.

    ReplyDelete